Skip to content
By Seb PlaceUpdated

Published · 7 minute read

Where this guide disagrees with Which? on Octopus Energy

Ad Links marked Ad are my referral links.

TL;DR

Which? has named Octopus a Recommended Provider for nine consecutive years. Here's where my six-year customer perspective lines up with theirs, and the one place it doesn't.

If you just need the link, you can get your Octopus Energy referral code here.

Your reward: £50 account credit

Ad Use referral link (opens in new tab)

Affiliate disclosure: this post contains an Octopus Energy referral link. If you use it, both of us get £50 bill credit: the same £50 any Octopus referral earns, just attributed to me. It doesn't change the price you pay or the tariff you can pick.

Which? (opens in new tab) runs an annual customer-satisfaction survey of UK energy suppliers, and Octopus Energy has been a Which? Recommended Provider for nine consecutive years (opens in new tab). My own Octopus Energy review, now six and a half years in and gas-only since I moved my electricity to EDF in July 2026, mostly lines up with their conclusion: Octopus is one of the strongest UK domestic suppliers on the criteria that matter most to most households.

But not all of my position lines up with theirs. One place, specifically. This post sets out where we agree, then that one place.

Where Which? and I agree

Customer service. Which?'s satisfaction surveys consistently place Octopus at or near the top of UK domestic suppliers on the dimensions they measure: billing accuracy, complaint handling, ease of contact, switching experience. That matches my six and a half years as a customer, electricity to July 2026 and gas throughout: two house moves with zero friction, same-day email replies, in-app chat that resolves most things in minutes, and one 25-minute phone wait across nearly seven years (more on that in the main review).

Independence and scale. Which? notes that Octopus passed the 2021–22 supplier-failure cull cleanly when dozens of smaller suppliers went under, and has since become the largest UK electricity supplier (opens in new tab), serving 6.8 million UK households on a 22% market share when it announced that in April 2024. I agree that scale matters here. A supplier you depend on for an essential utility needs the balance sheet to survive wholesale shocks.

Trustpilot. Octopus sits at 4.8/5 from over 700,000 reviews (opens in new tab) (April 2026), which is high for a regulated utility. Which?'s survey-based satisfaction scores and Trustpilot's volunteered ratings agree.

The 2026 ranking. Which?'s 2026 survey (opens in new tab) scored Octopus 74% overall, ahead of E.ON Next's 66%, which Which? calls the highest-ranked of the traditional big firms. I ran Octopus electricity and E.ON Next gas side by side for nearly four years (my Bulb gas account moved to E.ON Next when Bulb failed in 2021), and I'd put them in the same order: E.ON Next is responsive and competitive on dual-fuel Fixed pricing, but Octopus is the one I pick.

The Recommended Provider streak is meaningful. Nine consecutive years through a wholesale-price crisis, an industry shake-out, and an Ofgem standing-charge reset is a signal of stability.

Where I disagree: Which?'s methodology under-credits smart tariffs

Which?'s energy satisfaction survey is built around the universal experience all UK domestic customers share: billing, complaint handling, switching, ease of contact, and price perception. Those are the dimensions that apply to every household, so they're the dimensions Which? scores.

What that methodology doesn't fully capture is the financial upside of being on the right smart tariff. The customers benefiting most from Octopus's tariff range (EV owners on Intelligent Octopus Go saving £400 to £800 a year on overnight charging, solar + battery households on Flux running near-break-even on bills, heat-pump households on Cosy) are a minority of the customer base. The Which? scoring spreads their satisfaction across the broader sample, so the tariff-range upside shows up as a modest contributor to the overall score rather than as the differentiating factor it actually is.

That's a defensible methodology choice for a publisher serving a general audience. But it means if you're in one of those minority groups, the Which? score under-credits the case for Octopus over a supplier with a simpler tariff range. A 66% customer score at E.ON Next on a simple Fixed tariff is good for someone whose usage is flat. It's irrelevant to a household where the right tariff choice is worth several hundred pounds a year on top of any service-quality difference.

Two more things it scores only indirectly, if at all:

  • The Kraken platform. Octopus runs its UK operations on its own in-house technology platform (Kraken) and licenses it to other suppliers. That's why the app works the way it does, why bills are accurate without manual intervention, and why edge cases like a wrong meter reading get fixed in minutes rather than weeks. Which?'s survey scores reflect the output of that platform indirectly (via billing-accuracy scores), but it doesn't credit the tech directly.
  • In-house EV and heat-pump products. Octopus has been one of the most aggressive UK suppliers in shipping integrated EV and heat-pump products (Intelligent Octopus Go, Octopus Energy Services). Households actively transitioning kit benefit from one supplier handling tariff, charging and installation rather than coordinating three separate providers.

Which?'s score is the right starting point for households with flat usage and no smart-home kit. For households with EVs, solar, batteries, or heat pumps, the score is too coarse to drive the decision.

Where Which? is firmly right and I'd repeat their position word-for-word

The disagreement above is at the margins. The places I'd echo Which? exactly:

  • Leaving Octoplus and Saving Sessions out of the score. An earlier version of this post argued the opposite: that Octopus's rewards return more money to an engaged customer than any other major UK supplier. My Octoplus points ledger says the spin, Saving Sessions and a few one-off awards paid me £9.90 from October 2023 to July 2026, and I joined Saving Sessions whenever the notification came through. At under £4 a year, they are not a reason to pick a supplier.
  • No supplier should be assumed bulletproof indefinitely. The 2021–22 supplier failures killed Bulb, Avro, Green, Utility Point and dozens more. Octopus passing scale and balance-sheet thresholds is a positive signal, but customers should still factor in counterparty risk.
  • Customer service quality is the most-weighted single criterion for most households, and Octopus's score on Which?'s methodology is strong.
  • Price cap regulation means there's no single "cheapest" supplier in the post-2022 UK market. Standard variable tariffs are all bound by the same Ofgem cap. What varies is Fixed-deal pricing, smart-tariff structure, and rewards. Which?'s framing on this is exactly right.

So who's right?

We both are, on the criteria each of us prioritises.

Which? is right on customer-service-driven supplier choice. Their methodology is rigorous, independent, replicable across years, and applied uniformly to every supplier they cover. If you want one signal to drive a switching decision and you have flat household usage, the Which? Recommended Provider list is the right shortlist.

My position is more opinionated. For households likely to benefit from tariff innovation, I weight it heavily enough that the Which? score under-credits Octopus's case. For households who won't, I'd nudge toward Which?'s framing more cleanly.

Read the Which? coverage as the baseline, read my Octopus review for the six-year customer's view, and decide which of those describes your household better.

If you're going to switch to Octopus anyway, using an Octopus Energy referral link adds £50 bill credit at zero cost to you, payable after your first direct debit clears.

Where this guide disagrees with Which? FAQs

Did Which? rate E.ON Next ahead of Octopus in 2026?

No. In the Which? 2026 energy customer satisfaction survey (opens in new tab), Octopus scored 74% overall and E.ON Next 66%. Which? calls E.ON Next the highest-ranked of the traditional big firms, a group that leaves out newer suppliers like Octopus, which also kept its Recommended Provider status for a ninth year.

Why do you recommend Octopus over E.ON Next?

For households with no EV, no solar, no battery and no heat pump on a flat usage curve, I'd be comfortable with either supplier, and the Which? score, 74% to 66%, tips it to Octopus. For households who'd benefit from a smart tariff (Tracker, Agile, Intelligent Octopus Go, Cosy, Flux), Octopus has the tariff range that E.ON Next doesn't, and the Kraken platform that makes the smart-tariff economics actually work in practice.

Is Which? wrong about Octopus?

No. Which?'s methodology is rigorous and applied uniformly. My disagreement is at the margins of what their methodology is designed to measure. Which? scores customer-service quality and billing accuracy well. It under-credits tariff innovation because that doesn't apply uniformly across the customer base.

Does Which? credit Octoplus and Saving Sessions in its scoring?

Not directly, and on my own numbers it doesn't need to. Which?'s satisfaction survey measures dimensions every customer experiences (billing, complaints, switching, ease of contact), and Octoplus rewards, Saving Sessions earnings and free-electricity events reach only the customers who opt in. My Octoplus points ledger has the spin, Saving Sessions and a few one-off awards paying me £9.90 from October 2023 to July 2026, so leaving them out costs Octopus almost nothing.

Which? awards Recommended Provider status based on annual customer-satisfaction survey results combined with passing minimum threshold scores on key service dimensions. Octopus has held the status for nine consecutive years, which is a strong stability signal across a period that saw dozens of UK suppliers fail. The streak survived the 2021–22 wholesale crisis, the Ofgem standing-charge reset, and Octopus growing from a challenger to the largest UK electricity supplier.

Should I switch to whichever supplier Which? rates highest?

Read the Which? score as the baseline customer-service signal, then layer in: tariff fit (do you need a smart tariff for an EV, heat pump or solar?) and price-cap quarter (are there Fixed deals below the next forecast cap?). The Which? rating measures customer service, which isn't the same thing as the right supplier for your specific household.

You might also like

Sources

Seb Place

Referral Plug founder · Personal finance writer and UK consumer savings specialist

I specialise in finding people the best deals to cope with the ever-increasing cost of living. I like to review companies from everyday industries like banking and energy and try to provide a fresh mix of facts and unbiased opinions.

Last updated: November 2026

Ad Use referral link (opens in new tab)